WEEK 1: TWO CULTURES
The existence of two cultures has definitely impacted my
life. There is a geographic divide at UCLA, where the humanities and arts are
taught in “North Campus” while the sciences and mathematics are taught in
“South Campus”. A popular rhetoric, on campus therefore is that the north
campus students have the creative minds while the south campus students have
the analytical minds. Although this is an absolute myth of a claim, it places
me right in the middle as I have my foot in both camps. I am an Economics and
Financial Actuarial Mathematics double major, which means I take both the
humanities classes and the mathematics/science classes.
When CP Snow coined this phrase in his lecture in 1959, it
referred to literary intellectuals and scientists. He talked about a
communication gap between the two groups and predicted a rise of a third
culture, where there would be free communication between the two groups.
However, in his book, John Brockman, disagreed with Snow and instead claimed
that the third culture will be such that the scientists will have free
conversations directly with the public and replace the need for a middleman. I
think the modern society is closer to Brockman’s view than Snow’s. An example
of this would be the YouTube channel called StarTalk Radio, which is hosted by
an astrophysicist, Neil deGrasse Tyson. On this channel, Tyson talks about
representation of science in movies and other pop culture, and provides
scientific explanation in a way that the general public can understand. He also
looks at some common pseudoscience questions or myths, and analyses them
scientifically. This is a great example of scientists taking over the
traditional role of literary intellectuals.
Before this week, I did not have a think about this debate,
even though I came across it numerous times. I agree with Snow and Brockman, that
a third culture has risen and a bit of both their visions is within this third
culture. In this age, when specialization is given so much importance, I think
it is definitely worth broadening one’s horizon. For me, doing this double
major has been very taxing, but at the same time very enlightening.
Comments
Post a Comment